Hasan Piker Is the Last Person Who Should Teach Jews Their History
He told Ezra Klein that Israeli fear isn’t justified. Jewish history says otherwise.
I did it. I watched Hasan Piker on Ezra Klein; it was excruciating, but I made it. My conclusion is that Hasan Piker is one of the least qualified people in this universe to tell Jews what they should fear. On his show this week, Ezra Klein asked Hasan Piker about Israelis’ deepest fear. He described an Israeli who had marched for two states for years and then lost a nephew in a bombing: “Hasan Piker might believe we’re going to be safe, but I don’t believe we’re going to be safe.”
Piker confidently answered with a history lesson. He said that “with the exception of maybe the Haitian revolution, there has never been an instance where the newly freed population has actually engaged in the act of righteous vengeance.”
The excellent Israeli analyst Nadav Eyal called this “the art of bullshit.” He warned that it turns into something more dangerous once it’s dressed up as serious analysis. Hatred and bigotry presented like a reasonable and rational argument can persuade people, especially those who don’t know any better. Nadav is spot on, and the rest of the conversation shows why.
Now, the actual historical record is full of examples that prove Piker wrong despite their inconvenience to his argument and worldview, and we Jews don’t need to look far for them. Jews were told they’d be safe as a minority in Hebron in 1929, where a centuries-old community of mostly religious, non-Zionist Jews was attacked and 67 were butchered by Arab rioters, and in Baghdad, until the Farhud killed nearly two hundred Jews in two days in 1941. My father’s family fled Iraq ten years later, after my grandfather had been arrested and wrongly accused of being a Zionist spy. They were part of the roughly 850,000 Jews who left or were driven out of the Arab world. My mother’s side of the family, the part that wasn’t lucky enough to move to North America, was erased by the Nazis. I could spend thousands of words on other examples, but you get the point. Israel was built by people who didn’t take Jewish safety for granted, and didn’t trust promises like Hasan Piker’s.
But Piker went further. “I personally don’t think that fear is justifiable,” he said, “even despite the horrific actions that took place on Oct. 7.” He said this about a country where most people know someone who was murdered, kidnapped, or killed fighting since that day. Piker streams from California.
Klein reminded him that he once called Hamas “a thousand times better” than the Israeli government. Piker didn’t take it back; he went on to defend Hamas’s motives. He explained that Hamas isn’t driven by hatred of Jews: if Israel were a Christian state, he said, the violence would look anti-Christian. All this despite the fact that Hamas’s founding charter quotes the hadith about the stones and trees crying out that a Jew is hiding behind them, waiting to be killed. Weeks after October 7, senior Hamas official Ghazi Hamad promised to do it “again and again.” Piker’s only concession was that he “probably wouldn’t do so well living under Hamas governance.”
The people who are “a thousand times better” targeted some of the most liberal Israelis, like the peace activist Vivian Silver and Hayim Katsman, people who literally dedicated their lives to coexistence and to helping their Palestinian neighbors. They livestreamed families on the victims’ own social media accounts after murdering their children.
He continued by defending his comparison of liberal Zionists to Nazis. I’m a liberal Zionist. I support a Palestinian state, I oppose Israeli policies in the West Bank, and I criticize the Israeli government constantly. His complaint about people like me is that we “don’t actually map it out.” If only he knew! (And he clearly doesn’t.) Mapping it out is literally my day job. I work every day, alongside many Israelis and Palestinians who have spent decades on these questions, on everything from near-term issues like rolling back de facto annexation in the West Bank, confronting settler violence, improving Palestinian access and movement without compromising Israeli security, and setting a plan to stabilize Gaza, to longer-term issues such as borders, settlements, Jerusalem, refugees, and security arrangements. When Klein asked about his own map, Piker said one state would go “through a potential binational commitment” and then “continue to build from that,” and left it there.
I’ll give Ezra Klein a bit of credit. Having watched the whole thing, I can say he did push back, not to the degree I would have liked, but more than his critics will admit. He called the Nazi comparison offensive and told Piker this isn’t South Africa, since there are about seven million people on each side. But that is the bare, bare minimum, and hosting him for an hour on one of America’s most prominent opinion podcasts tells listeners that Piker’s views on Israel deserve serious engagement.
But Ezra, come on achi. He compared people like us to the Nazis, the people who actually murdered our ancestors, and you told him you didn’t think he really meant it.
The fact that this comparison got only mild pushback, from a Jewish host I’d consider a liberal Zionist, albeit an apathetic one, shows how an uninformed streamer in a vintage suit, who once said America deserved 9/11, can become one of the loudest voices on Israel for a generation raised on campus slogans and TikTok conspiracy theories.
This shouldn’t stop us Israelis from being honest about who hands him his material, and from looking in the mirror at our own actions. I don’t think I’d heard of Hasan Piker before this government took office. He was a Twitch star, but he wasn’t close to the mainstream. Now he’s on the New York Times’ flagship podcast. When Piker calls Israel genocidal, he doesn’t need to look far or invent evidence like he used to. Our outgoing government has handed it to him on a silver platter. Israel’s national security minister said on a podcast this summer that Israel should kill “30 to 40” people in Gaza every night, adding: “They’re not even people.” The finance minister said starving two million Gazans might be “justified and moral,” and complained only that the world wouldn’t let Israel do it. The heritage minister called a nuclear bomb on Gaza one of the options.
Itamar Ben Gvir is not fringe. Days before the election, Netanyahu stood in Lod and promised: “Ben-Gvir will be a high-ranking minister with us.” Then Israel’s Arab citizens did what democracy asks of them and voted in record numbers.
Instead of celebrating Israeli democracy, Netanyahu dealt with losing his majority by accusing the Arab parties of fraud, with shoddy evidence at best, and treating over 20% of the country as a threat for taking part. Gadi Eisenkot, now tasked with forming the next government, called it a “racist and violent” campaign. I doubt many of Piker’s followers heard that. Eisenkot’s liberal Zionist politics don’t fit their narrative, because of course, according to Piker, he would be a Nazi. But to those who know little about Israel, which I confidently assume includes lots of Hasan Piker fans, his talking points sound like analysis when the prime minister and his ministers keep confirming them.
I believe that Israelis and Palestinians will eventually live in peace side by side. I’m quite certain it won’t happen in the near future, but I believe it will happen. That will take robust security arrangements and mechanisms. It will also take leaders on both sides who can instill hope and sell compromise to frightened publics. Hasan Piker dismisses one side’s fear and ignores its history. Netanyahu and his allies have spent years dismissing the other side’s humanity. Between them, the space for moderates (or “liberal Zionist Nazis,” as Piker would call us) keeps shrinking.
The biggest promotion in TMG history: the Gadi Special
To mark Gadi Eisenkot receiving the mandate, I’m offering 67% off your first year of The Middle Ground, one percent for each of the 67 MKs who recommended him. The offer runs for as long as he holds the mandate. Subscribers get Notes from Tel Aviv, weekly personal dispatches from behind the story, and early access to special podcasts.


I thought the Klein podcast was a travesty. Made Piker seem like a regular David Axelrod with perspective on the election and a pundit’s expertise on Medicare. This normalization far outweighs whatever minimal, anemic pushback Klein extended to Piker’s Nazi/ KKK comparisons.
Ezra Klein is one of the least qualified Jews to Jew-wash antisemitic garbage like Hasan Piker. But then again, the entire progressive wing of the Antizionist Socialist Party (FKA The Democrats) excuses its blatant hate for Jews in general and Israeli Jews in particular using the words of virtue signaling narcissistic Azajews like Klein. Pathetic.