I did not watch Ezra’s interview with Piker. It is crazy that he gave him yet another platform. Having said that, Ezra did not do himself any favors, since all the comments from viewers make Ezra look like he was the bad guy!
Eli, thank you for another thoughtful and morally grounded essay.
What deserves particular emphasis is the asymmetry of risk. It’s easy to assure Israelis from a California studio that their fears are unjustified. If those assurances prove mistaken, however, it’s Israelis and Palestinians who must live with the consequences.
A promise of safety is not a security architecture, and a vision of justice is not yet a workable political settlement.
Your willingness to confront the failures of Israel’s own leadership while defending the legitimacy of Jewish historical experience and security concerns is precisely what gives your argument its credibility.
Thank you for reminding us that genuine coexistence requires more than confidence in one’s own good intentions.
I started reading your piece but when I came to the point about the Hebron massacre, to which you did not give any context (Zionist-British manoeuvring to establish a settler colony at the expense of the natives, racial discrimination, religious provocations and the violent repression of protest). I stopped for air. I started again and then you mentioned the Jews of Baghdad, again, without any context. I stopped for good there. I suggest you read Avi Schlaim for a more measured view about what happened in Iraq, and the Zionist role in those events. If even people like you can’t find justifications for Zionism that do not rely on lies and obfuscations, Zionism is truly fucked.
Ezra Klein is one of the least qualified Jews to Jew-wash antisemitic garbage like Hasan Piker. But then again, the entire progressive wing of the Antizionist Socialist Party (FKA The Democrats) excuses its blatant hate for Jews in general and Israeli Jews in particular using the words of virtue signaling narcissistic Azajews like Klein. Pathetic.
I don't know why Ezra Klein is even bothering with that cretin. I'm guessing because he views Piker as an ascent force in the Democratic Party and wants the satisfaction of saying he interviewed him at this point in time. Ugh.
I thought the Klein podcast was a travesty. Made Piker seem like a regular David Axelrod with perspective on the election and a pundit’s expertise on Medicare. This normalization far outweighs whatever minimal, anemic pushback Klein extended to Piker’s Nazi/ KKK comparisons.
Totally agree. By platforming Piker, Klein is normalizing him, and that is dangerous. What on earth qualifies Piker the bigoted streamer as a political or international affairs expert ?
Why on earth is Ezra Klein platforming this ignorant bigot??? Of course he has no right to tell Jews what they should or should not fear. He is a raging anti-Semite; did anyone really think he would offer a well researched and respectful answer? There is zero reason to give this piece of garbage a platform.
Because Ezra Klein is on his side? At the end of the day progressive Democrats stick together, and at best express mild disagreement before backing each other to the hilt.
Never cared for Ezra but was otherwise neutral towards him. Giving piker a megaphone on his show is disgusting. I won't listen to it but I'll take your word that he could've pushed back more. Had Ezra been truly unwavering then my opinion could have been swayed. Pitiful
I finally listened to the show, and it only reaffirmed my opinions. In typical Ezra style, he provides knowledge (often with conclusions) on the topic before asking questions. It is gratuitous dialogue cloaked as an interview. The little pushback only gets lost in a cesspool of platitudes that attempt to raise the intelligence level of the discussion. I’m disappointed even by the moderate applause, though journalistic standards of late is all too embarrassing
Once the segment on Israel began, Piker offered his definition of Zionism; Ezra didnt reach, only to respond much later when it was too detached. Having heard enough, I skimmed the rest…bored and annoyed (mostly of the it's reception).
I did not watch Ezra’s interview with Piker. It is crazy that he gave him yet another platform. Having said that, Ezra did not do himself any favors, since all the comments from viewers make Ezra look like he was the bad guy!
Eli, thank you for another thoughtful and morally grounded essay.
What deserves particular emphasis is the asymmetry of risk. It’s easy to assure Israelis from a California studio that their fears are unjustified. If those assurances prove mistaken, however, it’s Israelis and Palestinians who must live with the consequences.
A promise of safety is not a security architecture, and a vision of justice is not yet a workable political settlement.
Your willingness to confront the failures of Israel’s own leadership while defending the legitimacy of Jewish historical experience and security concerns is precisely what gives your argument its credibility.
Thank you for reminding us that genuine coexistence requires more than confidence in one’s own good intentions.
I started reading your piece but when I came to the point about the Hebron massacre, to which you did not give any context (Zionist-British manoeuvring to establish a settler colony at the expense of the natives, racial discrimination, religious provocations and the violent repression of protest). I stopped for air. I started again and then you mentioned the Jews of Baghdad, again, without any context. I stopped for good there. I suggest you read Avi Schlaim for a more measured view about what happened in Iraq, and the Zionist role in those events. If even people like you can’t find justifications for Zionism that do not rely on lies and obfuscations, Zionism is truly fucked.
Ezra Klein is one of the least qualified Jews to Jew-wash antisemitic garbage like Hasan Piker. But then again, the entire progressive wing of the Antizionist Socialist Party (FKA The Democrats) excuses its blatant hate for Jews in general and Israeli Jews in particular using the words of virtue signaling narcissistic Azajews like Klein. Pathetic.
Piker didn't know what the Wailing Wall was til like last year.
I don't know why Ezra Klein is even bothering with that cretin. I'm guessing because he views Piker as an ascent force in the Democratic Party and wants the satisfaction of saying he interviewed him at this point in time. Ugh.
Ezra Klein is an Anzi Jew for the Genocide of Israeli Jews, like plenty of progressive Jew apologists for Piker and El Sayed and Darializa.
I thought the Klein podcast was a travesty. Made Piker seem like a regular David Axelrod with perspective on the election and a pundit’s expertise on Medicare. This normalization far outweighs whatever minimal, anemic pushback Klein extended to Piker’s Nazi/ KKK comparisons.
Totally agree. By platforming Piker, Klein is normalizing him, and that is dangerous. What on earth qualifies Piker the bigoted streamer as a political or international affairs expert ?
Why on earth is Ezra Klein platforming this ignorant bigot??? Of course he has no right to tell Jews what they should or should not fear. He is a raging anti-Semite; did anyone really think he would offer a well researched and respectful answer? There is zero reason to give this piece of garbage a platform.
Because Ezra Klein is on his side? At the end of the day progressive Democrats stick together, and at best express mild disagreement before backing each other to the hilt.
Never cared for Ezra but was otherwise neutral towards him. Giving piker a megaphone on his show is disgusting. I won't listen to it but I'll take your word that he could've pushed back more. Had Ezra been truly unwavering then my opinion could have been swayed. Pitiful
I finally listened to the show, and it only reaffirmed my opinions. In typical Ezra style, he provides knowledge (often with conclusions) on the topic before asking questions. It is gratuitous dialogue cloaked as an interview. The little pushback only gets lost in a cesspool of platitudes that attempt to raise the intelligence level of the discussion. I’m disappointed even by the moderate applause, though journalistic standards of late is all too embarrassing
Once the segment on Israel began, Piker offered his definition of Zionism; Ezra didnt reach, only to respond much later when it was too detached. Having heard enough, I skimmed the rest…bored and annoyed (mostly of the it's reception).