36 Comments
User's avatar
Vance Weber's avatar

Unfortunately you Eli are both “naive and blind”. The Democratic Party machine, left wing candidates ( are there really any others in the Dem Party except for Fetterman?) and multiple elected officials, even liberal Jewish ones ( Schumer ) have already made their beds, they have already signed onto the palestinian issue as they see it. It is their cause celebre.

In public they say it is the current Israeli government that is an obstruction to peace. But there is no way out for these politicians. They cannot shift their views towards moderation, because the extreme left controls this narrative and this party. Their political futures in the Dem Party are contingent on maintaining a highly critical position of the State of Israel regardless of the government. And haven’t we already been through this before over the last 75 years?

To Beinart, I have nothing but loathing. Or is he really Thomas Friedman in disguise?!?! Well what did Friedman achieve as a palestinian and two state solution advocate? Bupkis.

I don’t pretend to know the intricacies and nuances of Israeli domestic politics, but I surely understand what is happening here in America.

Israel must chart the course that the majority of Israelis desire. I stand by that. Israel must find a way forward with legitimate Arab partners.

The Democrats are chomping at the bit to chart a much more adversarial policy towards Israel. Obviously in the UK, with its growing Muslim population, and Muslims in powerful positions, and growing hostility towards Israel since, well since Oct 8, according to the FM statement, neither can one look there for positive viable input.

Appeasing cowardly, hypocritical leaders in the West will certainly be futile and fruitless.

Vikah's avatar

I think like Dan Senor, Israel holding itself to international law standards is not possible as it would be voluntarily submitting itself to examination and dismantling of its occupation infrastructure. Likely until international courts rule and or sanctions threaten the whole of israel’s economy, there is more to loose in conceding to the accusations mentioned in Millibrands speech versus waiting out the performative politics.

Tali Calderon's avatar

Partially true. It has been tried many times before. Two problems: 1. The Palestinians, until now, have shown no real interest in any real solution. 2. It does not help Israel win any argument. Israel should be doing it for its own sake, but shouldn't expect much by it.

Evets's avatar

To those wanting to counter accusations of genocide on Gaza nothing is less helpful than the current Israeli government’s countenancing/supporting an ever escalating series of pogroms on the West Bank. It nearly cuts the legs out from the argument against intention.

steak's avatar

LOL!!!

"These protests didn’t call for a two-state solution, the release of the hostages, or the removal of Hamas — they were hate marches directed at Israel."

See we hadn't yet committed genocide, so instead of those protests being correct in every sense of the word, they were just hate for a thing Israel might not actually do.

Frank Clapsaddle's avatar

Look at the wall Egypt has built to keep the Palestinians out- who whether Jew or not believes Israel should build less???

Jesus who believes there is a silver lining after all of the terrorism well before October 7th and since.

Tunnel after tunnel. Please remove the appeaser- stand with Israel-

Brad Spellman's avatar

Eli, count me among the Democrats you believe are reachable. I’m still a liberal Zionist, and I’m hardly alone.

You’re right about the mirror. Miliband’s “you were right” was addressed to marches that never called for two states or the hostages’ release, and that should be said plainly. But Smotrich and Ben Gvir wrote him the material, and pretending otherwise is exactly the easy out you describe.

On Barghouti, I’d go further than you did: Beinart’s call to free him deserves a flat no. And the principle is the same one you articulate: a different future requires different leaders. Israelis deserve better than Ben Gvir and Smotrich. Palestinians deserve better than a man convicted of five murders, and better than the movement that planned October 7.

That isn’t giving up on Palestinians. It is refusing the idea that Palestinian self-determination must forever be represented by men and movements shaped by political violence.

There is still room for a politics that holds two truths at once: Palestinian children deserve dignity, freedom, and possibility — and Israel is not temporary, provisional, or negotiable.

Some of us are still here, Eli.

Gabrielle G's avatar

Refreshing. Thanks.

Barbara Issahary's avatar

I think you don’t see the big picture at all. You completely miss it .

Look at who Burnham and Miliband are proudly smiling at and shaking hands with: - Qatar, Turkey and Iran. Get the picture now?

Eli Kowaz's avatar

As I said in the piece, there are other factors at play, UK politics among them. That doesn't excuse us from looking in the mirror. And fwiw, it was the Netanyahu government that spent years cozying up to Qatar, allowing suitcases of cash into Gaza and treating it as a partner. If you want to talk about who's shaking hands with whom, that's worth including too.

Barbara Issahary's avatar

I’m Israeli- I support Yair Golan and the left wing party. I want a two state solution, if possible. I hate this Israeli government and have protested against it for years. That doesn’t mean I’m blind.

There is nothing moral about labour’s stand - it is purely about getting the Muslim vote because their voting bloc is moving over to the Greens Party (the Gaza Party). {BTW - I liked Stammer although he was often misled, too. But Burnham and Miliband are completely devoid of moral principles).

Alex Stein's avatar

I think it’s very simple. The only way Israel can possibly win the argument is if it makes a serious effort to resolve the conflict with the Palestinians and to end the situation where they live under a violent military occupation. Micah Goodman can’t ride in on a horse with his Catch 67 to save us anymore.

SM's avatar

Would you consider something like the Allon plan, with control over Jordan Valley in addition to the large settlement blocks, adequete? Because no Israeli governement is going to leave the Jordan Valley after Oct 7 I dont think....

Hutch's avatar

There is no solution because any power or autonomy given to Palestine would be used to attack and attempt to destroy Israel. The Palestinian State experiment *was* Gaza 2005-2023. Utter, abject failure.

Even if you believe the PA differs meaningfully from Hamas, Hamas can conquer the WB just like they did to Gaza. And then you will have a territory 15x the size of Gaza, with direct line of sight on Jerusalem, the airport, and can easily cut Israel in two with a Gaza-style invasion.

Alex Stein's avatar

If there’s no solution the you should say you are happy for Israel’s isolation to worsen, as it inevitably will, even if there will be twists and turns on the way.

Hutch's avatar

I also think that, contrary to you, a strong Israel (that does not cow to demands for a fake Palestine state) will withstand the calls for international sanctions *better* than a weak Israel that capitulates.

Look at Oct 7th: it enervated all of the Israel haters. Blood brings out the sharks.

The best thing Israel can do is to *win* in Gaza and in Lebanon, and IMO that means permanent loss of territory (security burgers established in Gaza and in Lebanon). You can call that "occupation" but that's the price of security.

Dan Schueftan: "things will get worse, but we will get stronger faster than things get worse."

Alex Stein's avatar

Ok what will you do with the two million Gazans given that ‘voluntary migration’ is not an option given that no country wants to be see collaborating with the Kahanist agenda?

Hutch's avatar

Why should I be happy about it? It's terrible.

I just don't put all the onus on Israel, when it's clear that Palestinians have agency, as do all the Western countries that are declining rapidly and succumbing to Jew hate. It's awful for Jews whether in the diaspora or in Israel.

Alex Stein's avatar

This idea of these countries declining is a classic right wing fantasy that typifies an inability to separate one’s desires from the the way the world actually is. Yes, there are plenty of problems in these countries, but there are plenty of problems in ours - and arguably far more existential. This talk as if western countries are suddenly going to turn into anarchic wastelands is a weird fantasy. And also yes there are some problems for the Jews in the diaspora but in general their lives are much more stable for them there which is why most don’t want to make Aliyah.

Danny Kaye's avatar

So were previous Israeli efforts to solve the conflict, that ended disastrously, unserious? What should be done differently? (And don't say "start with preventing the exactions committed by the settler extremists" because that just means upholding the rule of law - it is self evident but it is no solution by itself. )

Alex Stein's avatar

We should start by making clear that we want to end the conflict with the Palestinians once and for all and find a way to share the land.

OverFlowError's avatar

That sounds at least a bit like Camp David 2000 ‘been there done that’ kinda thing… . It seems simply not possible with a Hamas Gaza.

Eli Kowaz's avatar

I agree with you Alex and Israel doesn’t necessarily need to be successful it just needs to show a willingness to keep the option open.

Saul's avatar

Do you not think Alex, that the Palestinians are simply not (yet) capable of self-rule? As you know, it’s not for the lack of trying. Ironically the more the “international community” (or its remnants) pushes Israel, the less is required of the Palestinians.

Alex Stein's avatar

We can have continued occupation if we want. But then we won’t be able to complain if the international situation gets worse.

Usually Wash's avatar

Ending the occupation though is likely to make the international situation get even worse. Gaza is far more of an issue than the West Bank. If the IDF leaves you’ll get violent Palestinian terrorists, more war, more dead Palestinians etc.

Of course, removing the far right parties from the government, not massively expanding isolated settlements, cracking down on settler violence etc would help.

Saul's avatar

We could complain but it wouldn't matter. However given the state of the UK/France/Germany, I believe the occupation has a decent chance of lasting longer than the integrity of the UK. Clearly President AOC would be problematic to put it mildly.

Tali Calderon's avatar

On the one hand you are completely right. It is essential for Israel to move away from a messianic right wing Government, first of all for internal reasons. On the other hand, Israel must understand that European countries are going to become more and more like Arab countries in the 80s. This is the choice they have made and this is the ideology they have imported. Israel hatred is the pressure valve that will be used more and more by Western governments. So I think that Israel needs to do better for its own sake while finding new alliances in addition to the Western ones, which will probably be less and less reliable.

The Hidden Premise's avatar

I don’t think Senor is afraid to look in the mirror and call out injustice & poor thinking - far from it.