3 Comments
User's avatar
Danny Kaye's avatar

A commission of inquiry is necessary to maintain accountability. Accountability is essential to maintain competence of the authorities. Competence is all that makes Israel's survival possible among its neighbors. So a commission of inquiry is essential.

However this government is marked by its extreme incompetence, over anything else. And incompetent ministers appoint incompetent yes-men. Their attempt to reduce the court's power is foremost in order to escape accountability. This is why they will never agree to mount an impartial commission. And this is why the FlyDubai fiasco, which ended well only thanks to the amazing heroism of all involved and miraculous amounts of luck, should be subject to a commission of inquiry as well - but won't, for the reason stated above.

As to the deep reasons for the 10/7 fiasco, I don't think we need a commission of inquiry to establish them. The "conceptsia", shared by almost all, was that they simply won't dare - that Hamas has too much to lose to dare launch a massive attack - because in the end, "they" are like "us". If their lives improve, thanks to Qatari and UN cash, and to salaries from work in Israel, they won't want to jeopardize this. Unfortunately, it is not true. Hamas doesn't care in the least about its charges, about the lives of Gazans. It was reported that according to the documents retrieved from the Gaza tunnels, Sinwar even considered it likely that Israel would attack Gaza with nuclear bombs as a last resort. That didn't stop him. And that is probably the most depressing lesson from 10/7.

SR's avatar

I'm sorry for your loss, I lost a friend on 9/11 myself and others in the GWOT that followed. After living through the 9/11 commission period and having read much on the inquiries after the attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7th, 1941, I would caution you to temper your expectations. Admiral Kimmel and General Short took much of the blame for Pearl Harbor during the war, but no one really knew the extent to which we had compromised Japanese diplomatic communications due to the need to protect intel sources and methods during the war. The 9/11 commission revealed warnings not interpreted completely and information not conveyed between agencies. Ultimately I found little satisfaction in the search for answers and for fault. I imagine that a similar commission, no doubt made up of "experts" and wise men, will find similarly in this case. It will be everyone's fault and yet no one's at the same time. Blame ultimately lies with those who committed the attack and those who supported it, and satisfaction only comes with their death and destruction.

Brad Spellman's avatar

A deeply moving piece, Eli. The distinction between systemic failure and personal heroism is essential. May Benji’s memory be a blessing, and may his family and all the families of October 7 receive the answers they deserve.