Israelis Have Forgotten Life Without Netanyahu
Micah Goodman’s case for a unity government shows why that matters.
I am 36 years old. Benjamin Netanyahu first became prime minister when I was six, and he has held that post for the majority of my life. I believe most Israelis do not remember what it was like to live in Israel without him.
This dynamic has been on my mind after listening to Israeli public intellectual Micah Goodman make the case for a unity government on Haviv Rettig Gur’s podcast.
Goodman’s argument has three parts. First, Goodman argues that after a war that restored deterrence at the cost of Israel’s standing in the West, only a unity government has the flexibility to turn that victory into partial normalization with Lebanon, Syria, and Saudi Arabia.
Next, Goodman claims that only a government with Likud in it has the legitimacy to put down growing violence instigated by Jewish Israelis.
Finally, according to Goodman, unity would end the polarization between left and right and shift things to a battle of the mainstream versus the extremes. The opposition gives up on replacing Netanyahu, and Netanyahu gives up on Ben Gvir and the Haredim.
Goodman puts the odds of this scenario coming to pass at 40 percent. Rettig Gur puts them at zero.
I disagree with Goodman’s premise. He describes Israel’s loss of standing in the West as the price of restoring deterrence, as if the two came as a package. I don’t believe in this zero-sum calculus. We did not have to lose the West in order to make Israel’s enemies fear us. That loss came from choices this government made along the way and the irresponsible statements its ministers made.
Goodman is very thoughtful, but I think he underestimates what Netanyahu wants from a unity government. Nothing we know about Netanyahu suggests he would use it for anything other than political survival and moving to elections when convenient.
In 2016, the prime minister talked to Labor’s Isaac Herzog about a broader government as part of a regional diplomatic move, then chose Avigdor Lieberman as his minister of defense in a move that signaled a rightward shift (Lieberman was viewed as a firebrand then—how the goalposts have moved!).
In 2020, Netanyahu promised Benny Gantz a rotation in the role of prime minister. Bibi outmaneuvered Benny. In the podcast, Haviv noted that Eisenkot’s polls fall in the event that he sits with Netanyahu. Another election helps Netanyahu and hurts Eisenkot, which gives Netanyahu the stronger hand inside that coalition.
Goodman’s answer to all of this is that Netanyahu could be tempted by “liberty and legacy,” a pardon plus a historic move in Donald Trump’s last two years as president of the United States. But he could have gone for liberty and legacy many times before. Why would this time be different? Because he is older? Many of his followers look at him as a messianic, immortal figure, and I doubt he sees himself much differently.
Since this election, Netanyahu and Likud have claimed, without substantial evidence, that Arab parties stole the vote, and he has called a coalition with them treason. The Central Elections Committee says it has found no basis for claims of systematic fraud.
Netanyahu’s unity offer keeps him in the prime minister’s office and keeps his right-wing allies in. Goodman says a unity government would exclude Ben Gvir and the Haredim, but never explicitly excludes Bezalel Smotrich, who is arguably more dangerous to Israel than Ben Gvir. Indeed, the two espouse near-identical worldviews. Smotrich just doesn’t attract quite the same media circus as Ben Gvir. Still, we should ask why Ben Gvir is an illegitimate unity partner and Smotrich is not.
Eisenkot has said any party that accepts his principles can join; that, in theory, would include Smotrich, but Smotrich does not accept Israel as a democracy with equal rights for all its citizens. This is a man who said he wouldn’t want his wife to give birth next to an Arab woman. In practice, that door is closed. And to think that a government with Netanyahu and Smotrich in it could begin to repair Israel’s standing is wishful thinking at best.
Goodman also says that only Netanyahu has the standing to pull off a diplomatic move or put down the chaos at home. That claim can’t be tested, because Israelis haven’t watched anyone else try for most of their lives.
I think this skewed view comes from a pre-Netanyahu amnesia that Goodman shares. People don’t remember an Israel without Netanyahu, and the thought makes them uneasy even if they don’t realize it. Israel won wars, built an economy, and made peace with Egypt and Jordan before Bibi first took office in 1996. Ehud Barak, Ariel Sharon, and Ehud Olmert governed for a decade between his first and second terms, and the Bennett-Lapid government ran the country for 18 months without him. If there is a real process and real hope in Israeli society, any brave leader can lead it. I believe an Eisenkot-led government that includes Ra’am can begin to repair Israel’s image abroad, repair its institutions, and safeguard Israeli democracy.
Goodman said in 2024 that Netanyahu is the wrong leader for the Iran fight. Now, according to the Financial Times, Netanyahu calls Trump every day to press him to restart the war with Iran, all for what appears to be personal political benefit over strategic military considerations. Goodman envisions these next 26 months being used to collaborate with Trump on normalization. Instead, Bibi is pushing to restart a war after declaring that Iran no longer poses an existential threat.
Netanyahu received 46 recommendations to form the government, and Eisenkot received 67. The election results were clear. Eisenkot says Likud can join, but only under him. That is unity too, just not the Bibi-dominated unity Goodman suggests. Far from saving Israel, the false harmony Goodman wants would drag it further into self-destruction.


Eli, you are 100% correct. Bibi is a narcissist and we all witnessed how everything in these last three traumatic years was done to serve his own interests. I pray he does not sit in the government
If Israelis' dont give up the settlement project it's game over.